Choosing the Right One: In Ground vs Above Ground Pool

Choosing between an In Ground and Above Ground Pool for your backyard comes with its own set of pros and cons. Factors like cost, installation, aesthetics, and durability all play a role. In this detailed comparison, we’ll explore each aspect to help you make the best choice for your needs.

I will compare and score each criterion for in ground pool and above ground pool.

Cost

The first and most important criterion of all. That is the cost, this cost will include main types such as: Initial cost, installation cost, decoration and accessory cost, maintenance cost…

In Ground Pools

Initial Cost: $20,000 – $70,000: The initial cost includes the pool shell, excavation, plumbing, and basic components. The price varies based on the type of materials used (e.g., fiberglass, vinyl, concrete).

Installing Cost: $10,000 – $50,000: Professional installation includes excavation, plumbing, electrical work, and backfilling. The cost is higher due to the complexity and labor involved.

Customization and Accessories Cost: $5,000 – $20,000+: Some features such as waterfalls, slides, integrated lighting, custom tiling, and advanced filtration systems add to the cost.

Maintenance Costs: $1,200 – $3,000 per year: Due to the larger volume of water, more complex systems, and higher cost of repairs and replacements.

Approval Costs: $500 – $2,000: Requires multiple permits, including zoning, electrical, and plumbing. The process is more involved and costly.

Above Ground Pools

Initial Cost: $500 – $4,500: This cost typically includes the pool kit and basic components like the liner, pump, and filter.

Installing Cost: $200 – $3,000: Installation can be a DIY project or done by professionals. It includes site preparation, assembling the pool, and installing the filtration system.

Customization and Accessories Cost: $500 – $5,000: Include upgraded liners, decks, lighting, ladders, and pool covers.

Maintenance Costs: $500 – $1,200 per year: Includes chemicals, cleaning supplies, and occasional equipment replacement

Approval Costs: $100 – $500: Permits and approvals may be required based on local regulations. Typically less stringent than in-ground pools.

According to HomeGuide, the total cost of an in-ground pool ranges from $28,000 to $55,000, or about $50 to $125 per square foot, with an average cost of $35,000. Meanwhile, Bob Vila states that the cost can range from $39,000 to $80,351, with a national average of $57,938. These variations depend on factors like pool size, materials, and additional features like lighting and heating.

Above-ground pools are typically much more affordable. The cost can range from $1,500 to $5,000, making it a budget-friendly option for many families. Additional costs for decking or fencing can add to the total expense, but it’s still significantly cheaper than an in-ground pool.

Cost Comparison Chart

My scoresCost: In Ground Pools: 0 vs Above Ground Pools: +1

Installation Process

In Ground Pools

The installation of an in ground pool is a complex process that involves excavation, plumbing, electrical work, and finishing. It can take several weeks to complete and requires professional assistance. Forbes recommends hiring a professional pool installer for the job to ensure safety and quality.

Above Ground Pools

Above-ground pools have a much simpler installation process. Most kits can be assembled within a day or two, and some handy homeowners may be able to tackle the installation themselves. However, professional installation is also available for those who prefer it.

For In Ground pool: To make it easier to imagine, you can learn about the complexity of installing in ground pool here:

For Above Ground Pool: A DIY Installing Above Ground Pool process:

My scoresInstallation Process: In Ground Pools: 0 vs Above Ground Pools: +1

Aesthetics and Customization

In Ground Pools

In Ground pools offer a high level of customization. They can be designed in various shapes, sizes, and depths to fit your backyard perfectly. You can also add custom features like waterfalls, lighting, and unique tiling to enhance the pool’s appearance.

Above Ground Pools

While Above Ground pools have improved in aesthetics over the years, they generally offer fewer customization options. They come in standard shapes and sizes, and while you can add decking and landscaping to improve their look, they often don’t blend as seamlessly into the landscape as in-ground pools.

In Ground Pool Landscaping

Above Ground Pool Landscaping

My scores – Aesthetics and Customization: In Ground Pools: +1 vs Above Ground Pools: + 0.5

Durability and Lifespan

In Ground Pools

In Ground pools are known for their durability. With proper maintenance, they can last for several decades. Materials like concrete, fiberglass, and vinyl are commonly used, each offering different levels of longevity and resistance to wear and tear.

Above Ground Pools

Above Ground pools typically have a shorter lifespan compared to in ground pools. Most above ground pools last between 7 to 15 years, depending on the materials used and maintenance practices.

My scoresDurability and Lifespan: In Ground Pools: +1 vs Above Ground Pools: +0.5

Maintenance Requirements

Both of them require regular maintenance, including cleaning, balancing chemicals, and ensuring the filtration system is working properly. However, in ground pools may require more intensive maintenance due to their size and complexity.

My scores – Maintenance: In Ground Pools: 0 vs Above Ground Pools: +0.5

Safety Considerations

Safety is a crucial factor for any pool, especially for families with children. Both types of pools can be made safe with the use of fencing, pool covers, and alarms. However, I personally rate the safety of Above Ground pool higher than In Ground pool. At least the Above Ground Pool is designed to be higher than the ground (I won’t mention the Semi type), making the risk of accidentally falling into the pool much lower.

My scores – Safety: In Ground Pools: +1 vs Above Ground Pools: +1.5

Property Value

In Ground Pools

In Ground pools can add significant value to your property. They are often seen as a luxury feature that can attract potential buyers. However, it’s important to note that the return on investment can vary based on your location and the real estate market.

Above Ground Pools

Above Ground pools generally do not add substantial value to your property. In some cases, they may even be seen as a temporary feature that potential buyers would prefer to remove.

My Scores – Property Value: In Ground Pools: +1.5 vs Above Ground Pools: +0

Environmental Impact

In Ground pools typically have a larger environmental footprint due to the materials used and the construction process. Above Ground pools, being smaller and requiring less construction, generally have a lower environmental impact.

However, both types of pools can benefit from eco-friendly practices like using solar covers and energy-efficient pumps.

My Scores – Environmental Impact: In Ground Pools: -1  vs Above Ground Pools: -0.5

Total Score

 CriterionIn GroundAbove Ground
Cost0+1
Installation Process0+1
Aesthetics and Customization+1+0.5
Durability and Lifespan+1.5+0.5
Maintenance0+0.5
Safety+1+1.5
Property Value+1.50
Environmental Impact-1-0.5
Total44.5

Pros and Cons Summary

ProsCons
In Ground– High level of customization
– Long lifespan and durability
– Can increase property value
– Aesthetically pleasing
-High initial cost
– Complex installation process
– Higher maintenance requirements
Above Ground– Budget-friendly
– Quick and easy installation
– Lower maintenance requirements
– Limited customization options
– Shorter lifespan
– May not add value to property

As you can see, both In Ground and Above Ground Pools have their own perks and drawbacks. I won’t tell you which one to choose or push you to buy one.

The best pool for you is the one that perfectly fits your needs and lifestyle.

Happy choosing, Cheers!

Categorized in:

Basics,

Last Update: August 26, 2024