Solid and Mesh Cover – Which is best for you?
As the days shorten and the air cools, it’s time to close your above ground pool for the season. Before you settle in for those cozy evenings by the fire, there’s one important task left: winterizing your pool. A crucial part of this is picking the right winter cover. This cover shields your pool water, prevents freezing damage, and saves you money over time.
Think of it as your pool’s winter protector, making sure it’s ready for another season of fun.
In this article, we’ll look at the different types of above ground pool winter covers. We’ll guide you through the key features, the pros and cons of each type, and help you make the best choice to protect your pool investment.
Two Popular Types of Above Ground Pool Winter Covers
Mesh Covers – The Lightweight Choice
Mesh covers, made from materials like polyethylene or nylon, are light and let water pass through while blocking leaves and twigs. Their lightweight design makes them easy to put on and take off, and they usually cost less than other covers.
Benefit
Mesh covers are light and allow water to drain through, helping to prevent freeze damage. They also let some sunlight through, which can be both good and bad—it might help stop algae, but it can also help it grow.
Pros
Mesh covers are easy to use, reduce debris buildup, and are more affordable.
They’re simple to install and remove, making them a favorite for pool owners who want low maintenance.
Plus, since water can pass through, there’s less risk of freeze damage from water buildup.
Cons
The downsides of mesh covers are less protection from larger debris and the chance of more algae growth due to sunlight.
Mesh covers might not keep out twigs and leaves as well, and the sunlight that gets through can encourage algae to grow.
Best for: Minimal Maintenance
Ideal for pools that receive less debris and experience mild winters without heavy snowfall. A good option for those seeking an affordable and easy-to-manage cover.
Solid Covers – Keeping the Elements Out
Solid covers, typically crafted from heavy-duty vinyl, provide a solid barrier against debris, sunlight, and even precipitation. They offer a more comprehensive protection solution compared to mesh covers.
Benefit
Solid covers, usually made from heavy-duty vinyl, act as a strong barrier against debris, sunlight, and even rain. They offer better protection than mesh covers.
Pros
The main benefits of solid covers are their ability to completely block sunlight, stopping algae from growing, and their effectiveness in keeping debris and water out.
They are usually more durable and can handle stronger winds than mesh covers. Solid covers offer strong, all-around protection for your pool.
Cons
The drawbacks of solid covers include their heavier weight and the need to remove water from the cover’s surface regularly.
Solid covers are typically heavier and may take more effort to install and remove.
Also, since they keep water and debris out, any rain or snow on the cover has to be removed manually to avoid damage.
Best for: Comprehensive Protection. Suitable for pools prone to heavy debris and algae growth. Offers good protection in areas with moderate weather conditions. A cost-effective alternative to safety covers.
Keys Features to Consider
Material
The material of your cover is key to its lifespan and ability to protect your pool. Look for covers made from materials with strong UV resistance, tear resistance, and overall toughness.
Polyethylene (PE): Durable, lightweight, and has good water resistance. Many PE products come with UV-resistant layers.
Vinyl: Highly durable with excellent UV protection, often used for both winter and summer covers.
Ease of Use
Choose one that’s easy to put on without special tools or extra help, making closing your pool for the winter quick and hassle-free.
When spring arrives, you’ll appreciate a cover that comes off easily with minimal effort, making it easier to start the new swimming season.
Size and Fit
Most covers come in standard sizes, so you generally don’t need to worry about fit. However, if you have a uniquely shaped in-ground pool, you’ll need to pay extra attention to ensure the cover fits properly
Climate
Heavy Snow: If you live where it snows heavily, you need a cover that can support the weight of snow. Solid covers with strong wind resistance are often the best options.
Strong Winds: In areas with frequent high winds, pick a cover that can withstand gusts without coming loose or getting damaged. For instance, the Poolhacker type comes with a smartly designed winch cable. You simply cover the pool, twist the lock, and you’re done—no need to manually tie any ropes like with other types.
Maintenance tips
Winter covers require a bit of maintenance during the off-season. It’s important to check them periodically, especially after snowfall, and drain any excess water if needed.
Also, regularly check the cover’s tension and make adjustments as necessary. A snug fit ensures you get the most out of your winter pool cover.
Conclusion
We’ve covered the pros and cons of the two popular Winter Covers for Above Ground Pools. If you live in a cold climate with harsh winters, I recommend going with a Solid Cover. However, in milder climates like the South, a mesh cover is a good choice.
